Sugar, Spice & all things NICE

by niddler on 19th August, 2009 at 17:22

I’ve been reading with dismay about the unfair, uninformed and occasionally downright moronic criticism levelled at the NHS by conservative American politicians and pundits. It bugs me that there is very little we can do to refute their claims, as virtually the only people in the USA who are interested in finding out if their claims are actually true… are the people who don’t believe them in the first place. American talk radio and many of the other political websites/blogs/media seems to have polarised to such an extent that there is no voice looking to find the middle ground, or indeed the truth.

These days, if you listen to talk radio, read a newspaper or subscribe to a political blog in the US then you’re pretty much signing up to be told which prejudice of the week you’re going to follow. This isn’t just levelled at right-wing American politics; the Democrats aren’t a great deal better – just spouting opposing views.

My favourite criticisms thus far have been:

  • (Prof) Stephen Hawking wouldn’t have a chance in a medical system like the NHS – which obviously Stephen was a bit surprised about.
  • The National Institute for Clinical Excellence (NICE) is a “death panel” – deciding who lives and who dies based on how old they are. An extremely sensitive issue, and not actually what NICE are all about – instead, they’re there to reduce the “postcode lottery” of what drugs can be afforded in what places – a group of people (not just doctors, but patients and carers too) trying to even the score across the country as a whole. Yes they also say some drugs aren’t recommended because they’re too expensive, but that’s due to having a finite amount of money to spend and it can be better spent elsewhere – which is (in my opinion) not unreasonable when there’s a treatment that provides 95% of the effectiveness for 5% of the cost. I wonder – would all the campaigners for the drugs that cost thousands of pounds per dose have happily paid an extra couple of percent in income tax for the privilege before it was THEIR beloved relative dying?
  • British people are against the NHS – which came as a surprise to the people who starred in the video, who, although angry about specific issues, do still think we should have an NHS – they just want a better funded one.

but here’s my personal favourite…

I’m not saying the NHS is perfect, but I’d rather have an imperfect system that is provided equally to all, than a perfect system provided to the rich, while the poor are given the opportunity to die from practically anything, as even the most basic treatment costs more than they can afford.

I was particularly moved by searching for “Sutent and Nexavar cost” – to try and get an idea of how much these cancer drugs that NICE had denied actually cost. Lo and behold the first link I find isn’t one from the UK – it’s a bulletin board in the US saying how someone is desperate for these drugs, but can’t afford them ($5,000/month), and their insurance isn’t wanting to pay out – they’re no better off than if they lived in the UK – however even they are a lot better off than the poor suckers with no insurance at all, who end up selling everything they own to pay for treatment that (if they lived in the UK) would be free, perhaps not identical, but they’d still have a roof over their head.

I reckon the BBC, the NHS and the Royal Mail (ever posted something to “the house with the green door opposite the pub”?) are British institutions that don’t get nearly enough praise – so this post is my contribution.

Tags: , , ,

One Response to “Sugar, Spice & all things NICE”

  1. Tim Jeanes says:

    Hear hear! I love the NHS!

    They’re even lovely to people who aren’t strictly entitled to care.

    Karen’s dad injured his foot by kicking a burning television out of his house shortly before flying over here for our wedding. We took him to the hospital to have his dressing changed, and told the staff there that he wasn’t British and asked what we should do about paying for it. “Never mind that,” they said, and did it for free.

    He’s over here again now to visit his new grandson, and the cold he caught on the plane has turned into bronchitis. We phoned NHS Direct who told him to go to the hospital to see a GP there. All free again – I guess the cost of doing the paperwork is more than they’d claw back from charging for an appointment.

    Mind you, he had to pay full price for the tablets he was prescribed, instead of paying the flat fee of £7.10 that we’d pay. Fortunately antibiotics only cost £2 to make, so he was quids in there too.

    I guess that’s where the inequality comes in – we’d have to pay a fiver too much for some dirt cheap drugs. Still, if that means someone else gets the same drugs free because they’re young, old, unemployed or pregnant, and if someone else gets their $5,000 cancer drugs for £7.10, I’m all for it!

Leave a Reply