Not the most exciting thing I’ll have ever blogged about (no comments please about the excitement in any other post) but I’m kind of frustrated by the poor reporting of the recent budget changes – and this is my soapbox.
I’d like to clear up a few things. George Osborne seems to be credited with a whole load of things which existed in the past, and has actually done surprisingly little, although I’d argue that he’s perhaps done with a shotgun what he should have done with a scalpel.
Two things I should probably say before I continue:
Disclosure of interest; I work for a Financial Services company which does not sell annuities, but does have a range of Pension and Income Drawdown products.
and
Disclaimer; none of this constitutes advice, and you should consult a financial adviser before making any decisions about your finances.
So, here we go…
George Osborne has said [1]:
“most people still have little option but to take out an annuity”
and
“Let me be clear. No one will have to buy an annuity”
Sounds new! Is it?
Short answer: no.
Long answer: The ability to go into income drawdown (taking income from the pension savings you’ve made up until now) as an alternative to buying an annuity has existed since the 1995 Finance Act[2] (if you’d rather not read the raw legislation but want a source, Wikipedia has a good summary). The amount of income you were allowed to withdraw was set by tables created by the Government Actuary’s Department (known as “GAD” – I bet they have the best office parties). The income you could withdraw was reviewed every few years (with the maximum income being a percentage of the raw GAD table, the percentage was occasionally tweaked by the Chancellor), but the basic intent was to stop you running out of money.
Back in 1995 you were still obliged to buy an annuity at age 75, but that was removed in 2006 [3] albeit with some slightly stricter rules after age 75, and it was made even simpler in 2011 [4]. In 2011 they also introduced “flexible drawdown” with a “minimum income requirement” – basically if you could demonstrate you had an income from elsewhere of at least £20,000/year (such as an annuity, or a defined benefit pension), you could withdraw anything you liked from your drawdown pension. I guess the idea was, if you went and spent your whole pension pot on a new car and a nice holiday, you still had £20,000/year to live off, and so wouldn’t end up penniless (albeit with a flash motor and a suntan).
So far you might actually be wondering what George Osborne has introduced if it was all there already – well, he’s changed the maximum income from 120% to 150% wef from next Thursday (he increased it from 100% exactly a year ago, at about 6 weeks’ notice – this time it was only a week – I’ve got the day off today (Happy Anniversary Mrs Niddler!) but I imagine tomorrow I’ll be in a few crisis meetings being asked how we change the systems that quickly), he’s also halved the minimum income requirement to £10,000/year and said that from next year that will disappear entirely – other than making it easier to get more money quickly, the fundamentals haven’t changed.
I wonder whether the reporters for the major news outlets know anything about pensions – the BBC reported “People will also no longer have to use their pension pot to buy annuities” [5] and in an article describing what an annuity is, said “for those who save into a defined contribution pension, there was a requirement to buy an annuity or face a hefty penalty” [6]. They don’t seem to have heard of income drawdown then – and the “hefty penalty” seem to be referring to HMRC’s rules about unauthorised payments from a registered pension scheme [7] where a 40% tax charge is levied if the payment was not authorised. This is where people who sign up to the dodgy “get your money out of your pension, now!” schemes have been burned, as the person doing it will charge them a bucket to get the money, and then they’ll get hit by HMRC with a charge of 40% of it – not so much fun.
Now a couple of things to bear in mind; annuities and income drawdown both get taxed as income tax, just like a salary. In fact, if you have a salary and a pension payment then it’s like having two jobs, and the tax can get pretty complicated. So, if you’re already a higher-rate tax payer, and you make a withdrawal from your pension, you will actually get taxed at 40% (or even more if you’re super-rich) – although you won’t be on HMRC’s naughty list, it’s not actually a whole world apart from the unauthorised thing AND it’s something you’ve been able to do for ages.
Getting bored of the rant yet? Plenty more to go, but the summary so far is – not a lot has actually changed. Let’s look at the bigger changes…
1. Everyone approaching retirement offered free, face-to-face advice
I think this is a good thing – people need advice. I work in the industry and I still have a financial adviser – it’s useful to have someone who’s not emotionally connected to your money helping you out, and who has time to spend wading through legislation, staying up to date on everything, and probably having a better grasp of investment choices than the dartboard approach many people use.
The problem is that advice costs money, the adviser has to get this from somewhere, and since the Retail Distribution Review at the end of 2012 (RDR) banned product providers from paying commission to the adviser (the workload for that nearly killed me). As a result that adviser payment has to come directly from you the consumer – so if you’re not in the fortunate position of being able to front up a few hundred quid to get the advice, broadly, you can’t have it. It’s called “the advice gap” – the people who need it, but can’t afford to pay for it [8].
I think free advice is good – it bridges the advice gap – although is it free? The government is injecting £20m to start the initiative (sounds a lot, but it’s actually only £33/person retiring this year[9], so that’s a lot less than an hour’s advice), and the remainder will be obtained by a charge levied on pension providers [10]. Cor it’s a good job I’m not paying for that, and those nasty pension people are going to get their comeuppance and have to pay for me to get something for free for a change, hahahaha. Oh wait a minute, how will they get the money? They charge me for their service, so aren’t they just going to jack up the price of my pension? Oh, so I’m paying it after all. Rats.
Now, I still think it’s a good idea – people who have a pension and are going to get the advice at some point, so they should pay for it (and it’ll probably be quite a small sum per person in a pension as a relatively small fraction will get advice each year) – it’s a bit like car tax paying for roads – but what are they going to be advised?
At the moment the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) regulate how advisers operate, and give a lot of guidance about what is considered a good (“compliant”) way of servicing a customer. Unfortunately all that regulation and guidance is written such that it’s very simple to send someone to an annuity (and in fact, if they don’t advise you, but just give you the details of an annuity bureau “non advised” then they can get paid a commission – yes, because it’s not advised, they can be paid commission, which is banned under the RDR if they’d given advice… twisted? yes. Illegal? not yet).
Conversely, if they wanted to recommend income drawdown to you, then actually they would have to spend a lot of time and effort producing the “due diligence” to demonstrate they have been compliant with the regulations – it’s really stacked up against drawdown, including having to show what you could have if you’d bought an annuity (conversely, if you were considering an annuity there was no requirement to show what income drawdown might provide – like I said, stacked against drawdown). Now, if you’re an adviser and you get paid the same money for something either way, and one way takes a LOT more effort and you’re more likely to get in trouble with the regulator… well, you tell me… especially when most people have never heard of drawdown (not just people who work for the BBC) and are probably a little scared of the idea.
Not a comma of that regulation has been removed by the Chancellor, presumably there’s some frantic crossing-out going on at the FCA, maybe this new free advice service will be exempt from the rules… having looked into it a bit, it seems that although George said “advice” the government papers say “guidance” – which isn’t the same thing – so yes, they’re probably exempt… and not being subject to those rules means they probably won’t have to be qualified as an adviser, maybe there’ll be a 5 day training course (as opposed to the “first year of a degree” equivalent for financial advisers).
2. Removal of the limits
George Osborne says people can be trusted with their money. The minimum income requirement seemed a fairly sensible idea to me – ultimately this is perhaps more a question of political ideals than financial services, but I do think that there will be some people in the coming years finding out quite how hard it is to live off the state pension on its own.
3. Given the nasty annuity companies a kick in the teeth
Some of the big annuity providers in the market lost 50% of their share price yesterday. I don’t know a lot about how these things all interlink, but let’s hope it doesn’t mean any of them go bust – as that would obviously be fairly unfortunate for the folk who’ve bought annuities from them.
The other thing to bear in mind is that the really unpleasant stories for annuities were where companies had people saving pensions with them, and were then moving them into their own very badly priced annuities without giving them any hint of there being an alternative, as that made them a huge profit. Those annuities that were purchased on the open market were actually pretty competitively priced and although annuities aren’t necessarily right for everyone, the upside is that if you live a long time, you don’t run out of money. Heck, I’d consider spending at least some of my pension pot on an annuity for exactly that reason, although retirement is a way away yet.
4. Wow, look at all the lovely tax!
As previously mentioned, your pension income of any kind is taxed, George is letting people have it quicker, so that’s more money for the tax man in the short term – £1.2bn in 2018-9 according to the Institute for Fiscal Studies [11]. They also reckon the tax revenues will go down as people run out of money… I suspect there’s a lot of guesswork in that – as I doubt they’ve had time to ring up 100,000 people approaching retirement and say “what if you could just have it all now?” since yesterday. Time will tell.
So, what would I have done if I’d been carrying the famous red box? I’d have levelled the playing field – I think the free advice thing is great, definitely on my tick list, I’d have levelled the playing field between annuities and drawdown, which I’d say is a bit more scalpel, a bit less shotgun (using the terms from when I started the post… if you can remember that far back).
Now you can wow your friends with your knowledge in the most boring conversation at a dinner party. Just remember to wake them up when the main course arrives.