Posts Tagged ‘pay cuts’

Prophet warning

by niddler on 9th March, 2009

“Those who love money will never have enough. How meaningless to think that wealth brings true happiness!”

Ecclesiastes 5:10 (New Living Translation)

Words written by a king long since dead, still applying oh so accurately today (written by King Solomon in case you didn’t know – he’s not technically a prophet, but I couldn’t resist).

What’s got my goat (or other domesticated cud-chewing beast of your choice), is the figures that are starting to emerge surrounding the pay cuts announced at HP. Just in case you’re not up on the current situation, most HP employees in the US have been given a mandatory 5% pay cut, employees in the majority of other countries are being “asked” to take the cut, because they work in countries where employment law forbids mandatory cuts.

This might just seem a sign of the dark financial times, but it is not in response to the company making a loss and struggling to stay afloat… but less profit – a 13.5% drop in profits to be precise. Sounds pretty bad doesn’t it? Yes – HP only made $1.9 billion for the last quarter. That adds up to over $6,000 profit per employee – a little over $100 for each working day of the quarter… not a bad day’s work some might say.

There are a lot of disgruntled bloggers and many more angry comments from current and former employees – I think the one that captures the overall mood is “HP Pay Cuts – an unfair act of economic opportunism and greed“. The figure that stands out to me is that in 2008 the remuneration for the top 6 people at HP amounted to $142,774,325 – that’s not a comma where there should be a decimal place – it’s over a hundred million dollars.

I could wax lyrical about all sorts of things here, pointing out how many people in the third world they could personally feed, or how many times bigger than the pay of a regular employee that is, but there’s already plenty of those comparisons out there (although I will point out that their combined remuneration is bigger than the GDP of the Marshall Islands (population 63,174)), instead I’d like to return to the quote from Ecclesiastes…

“Those who love money will never have enough. How meaningless to think that wealth brings true happiness!”

If I apply this to my own situation I am left thinking I need to stop whining about having my pay cut – it won’t bring me true happiness anyway. That’s true, and I may well end up accepting the cut for the good of the soul, I find myself asking about the million-dollar men and women at the top of the company – do they deserve such vast sums – and regardless of whether they do, do they come home from work feeling like they earned tens of thousands of dollars in their (probably quite long) hours in the office / company jet?

Surely they have a hand in deciding their own pay, and therefore in some way must be demanding the ever increasing salaries – is it so that they can buy that extra home in an exotic location, or is it just keeping up with their neighbour who is a CEO at another company? Are they thinking that a little extra will be enough, and it will bring that true happiness?

Where do I go from here – do I take the cut? Do I take a moral stand against it? Do I just submit to their authority?

“give to Caesar what belongs to Caesar, and give to God what belongs to God.”

Matthew 22:21 (New Living Translation)

Jesus here was pointing out that everything else belonged to God – so really the issue wasn’t whether you should be paying a fraction of your income to Caesar (a contentious point at the time), it was whether you were giving your everything else to God. A challenging point that certainly challenges me.

If I do refuse the cut I might give the 5% of my salary I would have lost to help orphanages in India – those children sure don’t get to decide their own remuneration package, and yet, are the happiest kids I’ve ever heard of – maybe the warning from the prophet was right all along.